Rate this recipe

Chocolate
ice cream

Chocolate brings its own fat and solid particles, and both make the ice cream harder than a vanilla base. That’s exactly why so much homemade chocolate ice cream comes out of the freezer as hard as a rock. The solution lies in the ratio: less cream than you’re used to and a little more sugar, so it stays scoopable. Also, melt the chocolate in the warm milk and use cocoa powder as well. A little rum or coffee liqueur goes well with it.

Base: milk, chocolate and cocoa4 ingredientsGlass: ice cream dish
Chocolate ice cream recipe in the right glass
CHOCOLATE ICE CREAM ✶ MILK, CHOCOLATE AND COCOA ✶ ICE CREAM DISH ✶ MELT & SCOOP ✶

The chocolate ice cream recipe
for your table

How many people?
Ingredients
1 person
120 mlwhole milk and heavy cream, two parts milk to one part cream
30 gramsdark chocolate, 55 to 70 percent cocoa, finely chopped
11 gramsegg yolk, just over half a yolk per person
24 gramssugar and cocoa powder, five parts sugar to one part cocoa
Making chocolate ice cream: step by step
1

Heat the milk with the cream and cocoa powder until just below boiling, and whisk the powder in thoroughly. Remove the pan from the heat and let the finely chopped chocolate melt in it: it melts evenly in warm milk, whereas chocolate melted separately will immediately solidify into grains when added to a cold mixture.

2

Beat the egg yolks with the sugar until combined, then gradually pour in some of the hot chocolate milk, stirring as you go. Stir the mixture back into the pan and heat over low heat until it thickens. Strain the mixture and let it cool to room temperature before putting it in the refrigerator.

3

Cover the mixture and leave it in the refrigerator overnight. Chocolate firms up further in the cold, so the chilled mixture is thicker than you might be used to with a vanilla base. Don’t let that worry you: that’s why it contains less cream than regular ice cream.

4

Churn the ice cream in the machine, or freeze it and scrape it loose four times, every half hour. For stracciatella, pour melted dark chocolate in a thin stream into the churning ice cream just before it’s done; it will immediately harden in the cold ice cream into delicate, paper-thin shards.

What did you think of this recipe?

One click on a star is all it takes. If you’d like to add a comment, we’ll review it before it appears here.

Save this recipe

Send this chocolate ice cream recipe to your own email so you have it handy when you’re ready to make it. You’ll also get a €5 discount code on orders over €50, for the glasses to go with it.

You’ll receive the recipe, your discount code, and our newsletter with new recipes. You can unsubscribe with one click.

The story

Chocolate ice cream is not vanilla ice cream with chocolate in it. A bar of dark chocolate consists largely of cocoa butter, which hardens when it gets cold. It also contains solid cocoa particles, which do not bind water but do take up space. As a result, at the same temperature, the mixture is always firmer than a regular cream base. If you simply use the same cream and sugar as in your vanilla recipe and add chocolate, you’ll take a block out of the freezer. Using less cream and a little more sugar brings it back into balance, because sugar lowers the freezing point and offsets the firmness added by the cocoa butter.

The right glass

Chocolate ice cream comes out of the freezer firmer than vanilla ice cream and also melts more slowly, so the bowl should be deep. Our first choice below is a round footed coupe, described as 8.6 cm high and 10.9 cm in diameter, with room for a couple of scoops of ice cream plus whipped cream, sauce and toppings. The sturdy base keeps it stable even when full, and the clear glass lets you see the layers. The second is a solid runner-up: the description calls it a wide, shallow bowl for champagne and a classic cocktail without ice, so it is not intended as an ice cream coupe. It looks lovely with one scoop and a drizzle of sauce, but it is too shallow for a layered dessert. Deeper glassware for desserts like these can be found among the dessert glasses, and related shapes among the coupes.

Empty round glass ice cream coupe, 28 cl, on a sturdy base
Our choice 01

Onis Primavera Ice Cream Coupe 28 cl (6 pieces)

€ 25,95per set · fast delivery on business days
Empty, wide, shallow 22 cl coupe glass with a stem and vertical ribbing on the bowl
Our pick 02

La Rochère Perigord Coupe 22 cl (6 pieces)

€ 30,95per set · fast delivery on business days
Complete set

Both sets together € 56,90.

Shop the set →

The right tools

For chocolate ice cream, in addition to a glass, use a zester to shave dark chocolate into fine curls over each serving and a fine-mesh strainer to sift the cocoa powder before adding it to the milk, because stirring won’t get rid of cocoa lumps. These are the bar tools we use ourselves; find everything in our bar tools & cocktail sets.

Multi-purpose zester

Fine chocolate curls over each serving

€ 15,95
Fine cocktail strainer 8 cm

Sift the cocoa powder into the milk without lumps

€ 11,95
Everything you need in one click

Glass set (our pick 01) + 2 bar tools together € 53,85.

Add everything to cart →

What to serve with it?

Chocolate ice cream is rich and sweet, so serve it with something that balances it out. Rum and coffee liqueur are the obvious choices, and a glass of red wine with firm tannins works better with a high cocoa percentage than you might expect. On each drinks page, you can read about the alcohol percentage, what it tastes like, which cocktails it goes with and which glass you need.

Bottle of Bacardi Carta Blanca 70 cl

white, dark and spiced

Bottle of Havana Club 3 Años 70 cl

around 40% · Cuban rum

Bottle of Captain Morgan Spiced Gold 70 cl

around 35% · spiced rum with spices

Bottle of Malibu Coconut 70 cl

around 21% · rum-based coconut liqueur

Bottle of Kahlúa 70 cl

around 16% · coffee liqueur from Mexico

Bottle of Catena Malbec 75 cl

usually between 12 and 15% · full-bodied and robust

Bottle of Piccini Brunello di Montalcino 75 cl

around 14% · red wine from Tuscany

Variations & twists

This recipe also works without eggs: omit the yolks, add a little more chocolate and let the cocoa butter do the binding. The result is darker and has a slightly shorter finish, but it’s ready in ten minutes. A higher cocoa percentage in the bar means more flavor and less sugar, but also makes the ice cream harder, so above 70 percent, compensate with an extra tablespoon of sugar. It’s also easy to mix things in: chopped hazelnuts, a pinch of chili powder, a spoonful of strong espresso or a handful of amarena cherries. The best-known variation is still stracciatella. Need more inspiration? Browse more than 100 cocktail recipes.

Serving tip

Leave this ice cream out of the freezer a little longer than vanilla ice cream, about twenty minutes, because the cocoa butter needs that time to soften. Serve it with something crunchy, such as a crisp wafer or toasted hazelnuts, to balance the soft texture. Salt works well with chocolate too: a few flakes over the scoop are enough.

Good to know

Why does chocolate ice cream get so hard?

Because chocolate itself contains fat in the form of cocoa butter, and that fat hardens when it gets cold. Added to that are the solid cocoa particles from the bar and the powder, which take up space without binding water. If you use the same amount of cream as in a vanilla recipe, the fat builds up and the ice cream comes out of the freezer like a block. Less cream and a little more sugar bring it back into balance.

Why cocoa powder and chocolate?

They do different things. Cocoa powder is almost defatted and mainly adds color and depth, the bitter, dry side of chocolate. The bar adds cocoa butter, and therefore creaminess and mouthfeel. Cocoa powder alone makes ice cream that tastes good but feels mealy; a chocolate bar alone makes ice cream that is creamy but tastes flat. Together they complement each other, which is why both are in the recipe.

Why melt the chocolate in the milk?

Because separately melted chocolate stirred later into a cold mixture immediately solidifies again into tiny grains you can feel on your tongue. Pour the chocolate into warm milk, and the fat spreads evenly through the liquid and stays that way. Chop the bar finely first: large chunks sink to the bottom and melt unevenly.

What cocoa percentage should you use?

A bar between 55 and 70 percent works best at home. It has enough cocoa butter for creaminess and enough sugar in the bar. Above 70 percent, the ice cream becomes firmer and drier, so add a tablespoon of sugar. Milk chocolate works too, but halve the sugar in the recipe because the bar already contains a lot.

Can you make it without egg?

Yes. The cocoa butter in the chocolate already binds some of the mixture, so you can leave out the egg yolks and use a little more chocolate instead. Then you can skip the whole saucepan: warm the milk, melt the chocolate into it, stir in the sugar and cocoa powder, cool, and churn. The result is darker, a little less rich, and quicker to make.

How do you make it stracciatella?

Melt fifty grams of dark chocolate au bain-marie and let it cool until just warm. Just before the ice cream is ready, pour it in a thin stream into the running machine, or into the ice cream you have just scraped loose for the last time. In the cold, the stream sets instantly into delicate shards that break when scooped. Don’t pour in too much at once, or you’ll get a layer instead of shards.

Frequently asked questions

Why does homemade chocolate ice cream turn into a brick in the freezer?

Because chocolate itself brings cocoa butter and cocoa solids, which make the mixture firmer than a vanilla base. So use less cream and a little more sugar than in a regular ice cream recipe, because sugar lowers the freezing point and keeps the ice cream scoopable.

Why are both cocoa powder and chocolate used?

Cocoa powder is almost fat-free and adds color and depth, while the bar adds cocoa butter and therefore creaminess. With only powder, the ice cream tastes good but feels dry; with only a bar, it is creamy but lacks depth of flavor.

What cocoa percentage should you use for chocolate ice cream?

A bar with 55 to 70 percent cocoa is the best choice for home. Above 70 percent, the ice cream becomes firmer and drier; add a tablespoon of sugar. With milk chocolate, halve the sugar in the recipe.

How do you make stracciatella ice cream?

Just before the end, pour melted dark chocolate in a thin stream into the churning ice cream. It sets instantly into delicate shards that break when scooped. Add it in small amounts, or it will form a layer.

Everything for your bar,
to one address

Professional-quality glassware, sold in sets. Order today, delivered quickly.

Shop for glassware →